IPCC Notes GMCS ITT Time Table Syllabus Amendments RTP Suggested Answers: Income-Tax
Showing posts with label Income-Tax. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Income-Tax. Show all posts
// // Leave a Comment

Section 234E of Income Tax Act - Explained with Case Laws

Section 234E of Income Tax ActAuthor: Dingu

Of late this month we must have received lot of demand from CPC seeking demand for non remittance of Section 234E FEES (not Tax). Well here is something to crunch on about Section 234E.

234E will not apply to cases where TDS payment is made beyond the time limit prescribed for payment of TDS u/s 200(3)

There are two reasons:

Reason 1
Duty of person deducting tax.

200. 9[(1)] 10Any person deducting any sum in accordance with 11 [the foregoing provisions of this Chapter] shall pay within the prescribed time, the sum so deducted to the credit of the Central Government or as the Board directs.

12[(2) Any person being an employer, referred to in sub-section (1A) of section 192 shall pay, within the prescribed time, the tax to the credit of the Central Government or as the Board directs.]

13[(3) Any person deducting any sum on or after the 1st day of April, 2005 in accordance with the foregoing provisions of this Chapter or, as the case may be, any person being an employer referred to in sub-section (1A) of section 192 shall, after paying the tax deducted to the credit of the Central Government within the prescribed time, 14[prepare such statements for such period as may be prescribed] and deliver or cause to be delivered to the prescribed income-tax authority15 or the person authorised by such authority such statement in such form16 and verified in such manner and setting forth such particulars and within such time as may be prescribed.]

Section 200(3) says you have to file your Quarterly return AFTER paying the TDS within the prescribed time.

Well if i pay the TDS amount to the credit of the CG after the due date for payment there is no requirement for me to file my TDS return at all as per section 200(3)

When Charging mechanism fails where is the question of collection FEES Case law of Supreme Court P.C.Srinivasa Chetty

Reason 2

Okay We will harmoniously interpret the section in spirit along with section 201. After payment we have to file the Quarterly return!! i hope we all agree

Here comes the big one.

Section 200(3) says pay and file return else your TDS return is invalid / you cannot file your return. Fine i paid my TDs to government along with interest u/s 201 and filed my return immediately.

Part 1

Then you cannot charge me fees under 234E, since without payment of tax we cannot upload the return. If you are not accepting the return how can you ask fees for not filing Quarterly Return within the due date

LAW CANNOT ASK PEOPLE TO DO WHAT IS NOT POSSIBLE TO DO

Part 2

Let me recall  a splendid decision given a decade ago

Where no books of accounts are not maintained you cannot penalise him for not getting his books of accounts audited Ram Prakash C Puri – 77 ITD 210

Okay to the fun part

Department said you have not paid my tax pay interest (interest is compensatory in nature) We pay from due date for payment to date of payment. Now when i pay interest for late payment how can i / why should i again compensate the Government in the form 234E fees

Moreover 234E starts saying "Without prejudice to the provisions of the Act"   and does not start as 'NOTWITHSTANDING ANYTHING CONTAINED IN THE PROVISIONS OF THIS ACT' 

So Technically the Start of Days for 234E  Fees is from Due date from filling of Quarterly return or Date of TDS remittance which ever is latter..

I am open for discussion to the contrary on it.

Show More
// // 5 comments

Section 87A of IT Act Rebate Rs.2,000 for below 5 Lakhs Income

section-87a-rebate-2000-income-tax-service-tax
Income Tax Rebate under Section 87A was introduced by P. Chidambaram while presenting Budget 2013 and this Income Tax u/s 87A Rebate is applicable from Financial Year 2013-14, or in other words from Assessment year 2014-15.

P. Chidambaram while announcing the Budget 2013 introduced an Income Tax Rebate of Rs. 2,000 for people earning income below Rs. 5 Lakh. It is important to note here that Section 87A does not impact the Income Tax Slabs, and is a Rebate under Section 87A of Rs. 2,000.
Section 87A provides for Income Tax Rebate of Rs. 2,000 to Individuals earning Income below Rs. 5 Lakh. 
This Rebate of Rs. 2,000 would be given from the Total Tax payable by an Individual. It is pertinent to note here that this Rs. 2,000 is to be subtracted from the Total Tax Payable and not from the Total Income of an Individual.

Section 87A: Income Tax Rebate

As Section 87A provides for Income Tax Rebate, the taxpayer will first compute the Total Tax Payable and then reduce Rs. 2,000 from this Tax payable provided his Total Income is less than Rs. 5 Lakh. If his Total Income is more than Rs. 5 Lakh, the taxpayer won’t be able to claim income tax rebate under Section 87A.
  1. The Net Taxable Income of Rs. 5 Lakh is the sum total of incomes under all heads i.e. Salary, House Property, Business or Profession, Capital Gains and Other Sources.
  2. In case there is any loss under any head due to payment of housing loan or for any other reason, such loss would also be reduced from the total income.
  3. Deductions from Section 80C to Section 80U under Chapter VI-A would also be allowed and the resultant figure i.e. Total Income should be less than Rs. 5 Lakh for an individual to claim income tax rebate of Rs. 2,000 under Section 87A.
The above points have been represented below showing the manner of computation:-
section-87a-rebate-2000-income-tax

Salient Features of Income Tax Rebate under Section 87A

The following are the salient features of Income Tax Rebate under Section 87A:-
  1. Rebate under Section 87A is only available to Individuals. All categories of Individuals whether Male or Female or Senior Citizens are eligible to claim Income Tax Rebate under Section 87A. Other types of assesses like HUF, Companies, Partnership Firms, LLP etc are not eligible to claim Income Tax Rebate under Section 87A.
  2. Income Tax Rebate under Section 87A is only available to Resident Individuals and not to Non-Resident Individuals. (Recommended Read: How to compute Residential Status)
  3. The total rebate allowed under section 87A would be Rs. 2,000 or the total tax payable (whichever is less)
  4. Income Tax Rebate of Rs. 2000 is allowed before the levy of Education Cess and SHEC. In other words, Education Cess and SHEC would be levied on the tax payable after allowing for Income Tax Rebate of Rs. 2000
  5. There is no benefit of this Rebate to Super-Senior Citizens i.e. Individuals above 80 years of age as their Income up to Rs 5 Lakh is already exempted from the levy of Income Tax.
Show More
// // Leave a Comment

Amended: Section 115-O(1A) - Reduction in Dividend distribution Tax

Reduction in Dividend distribution Tax -section-115-o
Section 115-O of the Income Tax Act provides that dividend liable for Dividend Distribution Tax in case of a company is to be reduced by an amount of dividend received from its subsidiary after payment of DDT if the company is not a subsidiary of any other company. This removes the cascading effect of DDT only in a two-tier corporate structure.

With a view to remove the cascading effect of DDT in multi-tier corporate structure, it is proposed to amend section 115-O to provide that in case any company receives, during the year, any divided from any subsidiary and such subsidiary has paid DDT as payable on such dividend, then, dividend distributed by the holding company in the same year, to that extent, shall not be subject to Dividend Distribution Tax under section 115-O of the Act.


Analysis of the Amendment:

-If any holding company
-receives dividend from its subsidiary
-on which the subsidiary company has paid the CDT payable on such dividend,
-then, the amount of dividend declared, distributed or paid by the holding company
-by way of dividends, whether interim or otherwise
-shall be reduced by the amount of dividend, if any,
-received from the subsidiary company during the financial year.
-Provided that the same amount of dividend shall not be taken into account for reduction more than once.


Points to be noted

section-115-o-dividend-tax-income-tax
>Subsidiary company means only that subsidiary company in which parent company hold more than 50% in nominal value of equity share capital. Dividend received from other type of subsidiaries i.e., subsidiaries having Controlling Composition of Board, sub-subsidiaries, joint ventures, etc. shall  qualify for availing benefit under section 115-O (1A).

>Benefit of reduction of dividend is available on year on year basis, i.e., Dividend paid for one Financial Year can be claimed in the same Financial Year only. Carry forward of benefit is not allowed. Further, benefit can be availed irrespective of the fact that the dividend is paid for different financial year.

>Deemed dividend u/s 2(22)(a)/(b)/(c)/(d) is also considered for taking the benefit under section 115-O 

>Dividend on both preference shares and equity shares shall be considered
.
>Carry forward benefit is also not allowed.
Show More
// // Leave a Comment

Section 276B: Prosecution for defaults of TDS, Income Tax Act

section 276b income tax tds default prosecution 276 b section
By - Deepak k Gujarati


SUBJECT: TDS/INCOME TAX ACT

Default in TDS Collection and Deposit – How Punishable is This Offence


In the recent past it is observed that Income Tax Department is issuing show cause notices for launching prosecution u/s 276B of the Income Tax Act. Such notices are issued for defaults in payment of TDS. Prosecution has been launched even in cases where amount of default is low and period of default is of few days. Such an instance is found in Madhumilan Syntex Ltd. & Ors. Vs. Union of India & Anr. (2007) 208 CTR (SC) 417: (2007) 290 ITR 199 (SC).

Now the question arises whether in each and every cases prosecution proceedings can be initiated? There is no straight answer. Various courts have examined this issue. Points which can be used in favour of the assessee are summarized below:

Point no 1: TDS Default Amount and period is Important:

CBDT has issued instruction no. 1335 of CBDT, dated 28-5-1980 to the effect that prosecution should not normally be proposed when the amounts involved are not substantial and the amount in default has also been deposited in the meantime to the credit of the Government.

In the case of Vijay Singh Vs Union of India & Anr (2005) 199 CTR (MP) 653 the Hon High Court gave its judgement in favour of assessee for a TDS default of 28,776/- for a period of 5 months and some days. Also see BEE GEE MOTORS & TRACTORS & ANR. vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER reported in (1995) 127 CTR (P&H) 224 : (1996) 218 ITR 155 (P&H) : (1995) 82 TAXMAN 493

Point No 2: Absence of Reasonable Cause of TDS Default:

The provisions of section 278AA lays down that no person shall be punishable for any failure referred to in section 276B if he proves that there was reasonable cause for such failure.

It is essentially a question of fact to be decided in each case on consideration of material placed before the concerned authority. However the burden of proof that there was a reasonable cause for default is on assessee.

In SEQUOIA CONSTRUCTION CO. LTD. & ORS. vs. P.P. SURI, INCOME TAX OFFICER reported in (1985) 47 CTR (DEL) 277 : (1986) 158 ITR 496 (DEL) : (1985) 21 TAXMAN 13 there was delay in deposit of TDS. In view of reasonable cause shown by assessee, penalty proceedings came to be dropped by both appellate authorities. In this respect the court held that “Dropping of penalty proceedings must weigh with trial Court while judging the reasonable cause prevailing with assessee. Milder proof of reasonable cause must be taken to have been established. Continuance of prosecution proceedings would be a sheer exercise in futility and harassment of assessee—Prosecution was quashed”

Point No 3: Unintentional TDS Default is not punishable:

In  UNION OF INDIA vs. PYARELAL TARACHAND & ANR. (2003) 180 CTR (MP) 551: (2003) 264 ITR 525 (MP): (2004) 135 TAXMAN 97 the Hon High Court declined to interfere in the judgment where trial court acquitted the assessee because  it was not proved that the assessee has deliberately or intentionally committed the default.

Point No 4: Non deduction of TDS vs TDS deducted and not paid

After amendment of s. 276B w.e.f. 1st April, 1989, only if a person deducts tax but does not pay the same there is an offence. Failure to deduct tax has ceased to be an offence after the said amendment and it only attracts penalty under s. 271C. During the course of audit many a times it is observed that TDS has not been deducted on expenses incurred/provided at the end of the year. What generally is done that TDS liability is created as on 31st March by debiting vendor account. And the TDS liability is paid in current date. Thus there is a default from 1st of April to the date of payment. This will also attract prosecution provisions u/s 276B. On the other hand if instead of making TDS provision at the end of the year i.e. 31st March, the TDS liability should have been created on current date and payment made. This will make prosecution provisions u/s 276 B inapplicable.  See also Kaushal Kumar Biyani vs union of India through ITO (2002) 174 (CTR) MP 552

Point No 5: No Prosecution if it is a Company assessee:

Prosecution can’t be initiated against the company. It has to be initiated in the name of Director or Principal Officer responsible for TDS compliances. For initiating prosecution proceedings against the director of the company, the assessee officer has to give notice u/s 2(35) expressing his intention to treat such directors of a company as "principal officers". However, it would be sufficient compliance if in the show-cause notice issued to the company it is mentioned that the directors are to be considered as principal officers of the company.

In absence of both, permission is not granted to appeal against the judgment passed by Addl. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate whereby respondent director of the company has been acquitted of the offence under s. 276B. (COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. DELHI IRON WORKS (P) LTD. & ORS (2011) 331 ITR 5 (Del) : (2010) 195 TAXMAN 372 (Del)

Point No 6: Compounding Fees / Charges

If the assessee understands that there has been a default in deduction and/or deposit of TDS which may attract penal provisions of section 276B, he may express his consent to pay compounding fees/charges. Detailed guidelines have been issued by CBDT for compounding vide CBDT’s F No.265/26/2002 IT(INV) dated 29-7-2000 [263 ITR(St.)3] Such compounding can be done either before or after the institution of prosecution proceedings.

Few Observations

Keeping in mind the stringent provisions of law, first thing which is required is its strict compliance. Assessee is required to pay interest and penalty for various defaults. There is an urgent need for clear cut guidelines about the amount of Tax default and period of default which may attract prosecution.  This will not only save time of the assessee and the department but will also save assessee from undue harassment.

AUTHOR:  DEEPAK K GUJRATI FCA
Show More
// // Leave a Comment

HUF Formation procedure, Agreement and Tax benefits

By - CA Vinay Parmar

A HUF is a separate entity for taxation under the provisions of S.2 (31) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. This is in addition to an individual as a separate taxable entity. This indicates that a person may be assessed in two different capacities- as an individual and as a Karta of his HUF.

What is an HUF? As the name suggests, an HUF is a family of Hindus. However, even Buddhists, Jains and Sikhs are regarded as Hindus, and can, therefore, set up HUFs. The concept of an HUF has basically evolved from ancient Hindu law. There are two schools of law governing HUFs in India-Mitakshara and Dayabhaga-and there are quite a few differences in the rights and obligations of HUF members in each of these schools. However, since the Dayabhaga school is largely confined to Bengal, we shall, in this article, only consider the provisions of the Mitakshara school, which are applicable to the rest of India.

Basic criteria for an HUF

There are some essential conditions that must be fulfilled to qualify as an HUF. These are outlined below:

1. To form an HUF all you have to do is to get Married. The HUF is created the moment  you get married
2. Only one member or co-parcener cannot form an HUF;
3. The joint family continues even in the hands of females after the death of the sole male member;
4. An HUF need not consist of two male members. One male member is enough. For example, a father and his unmarried daughters may form and HUF.

Now the question is how to Create an HUF:

1. To create an HUF you need to create a PAN card.
2. Open a HUF Bank account,
3. Prepare an HUF Creation Deed by transferring ancestor Assets, gift to the HUF a/c.

The Million Dollar question is How to create capital In HUF:

1. If the members of the HUF transfer the money in to the HUF account, then Income tax clubbing provision willl apply, and the income will be taxable in the hand of the individual member.
2. But the Clubbing provision can be bypassed if the amount transfer in HUF account is invested in tax free scheme. The tax free income can  than be re-invested to earn even taxable income, Income on income is out of Clubbing Provision.
3. Gift can be received in the name of HUF from stranger upto Rs. 50000/-
4. Gift from relatives can also be received who are not the member of your HUF


Who can be members?

All the members in your family, including your wife, children, their wives and their children. While the male members are called coparceners, the females are referred to as members.

The senior-most male member is called the karta (manager), and a typical HUF consists of a karta, his sons, grandsons, and great-grandsons (all of whom are coparceners), and their wives and unmarried daughters (all of whom are members).


KEY POINTS IN CREATION OF HUF AND FORMAT OF DEED FOR CREATION OF HUF

1. Under the Income Tax Act, an HUF is a separate entity for the purpose of income tax return.

2. The same tax slabs are applicable to HUF as to individual assessee.

3. You can not transfer your own assets/money into HUF.

4. If you have ancestral property and earning some income from this property, then it is better totransfer this asset to HUF and save tax up to exemption limit applicable to individual.

5. You can transfer the money received on sale of ancestral property /assets into your HUF.

6. The income from property of HUF can be further invested in instruments such as shares, mutual funds, etc. and will be assessed under HUF.

7. Existence of property or multiple members is not a pre-requisite to create HUF. A family which does not own any property may still have the character of Hindu joint family. This jointness is understood in terms of faith and food. This is because as a Hindu is born as a member of the joint family.

8. Any gifts received by the members of HUF (birthday, marriage, etc.) can be treated as assets of HUF.

9. The HUF is taxable as separate person under income tax hence one can save tax from basic exemption of Rs. 2 lakh. HUF will also gain from the tax slab structure of computing income tax.

10. Apart from basic exemption of Rs. 2  lakh, section 80C deduction up to Rs.1 lakh is also available.

Then what you are waiting for just take the benefit of HUF if you are married and decrease your tax burden.

Regards
CA Vinay Parmar
Show More